All frameworks and cheat sheets

Reference table

Open textbooks and student outcomes: four studies

What the main syntheses found on learning, grades and withdrawal after switching to open textbooks

Table comparing four studies of open textbooks: learning stays about the same, while withdrawal and DFW rates fall after adoption.
Grades rarely move after an open textbook switch. Withdrawal is where the change shows up. Source: Hilton (2016, 2020), Colvard, Watson and Park (2018), Clinton and Khan (2019)

A table of four widely cited studies on open textbooks in higher education: Hilton (2016, 2020), Colvard, Watson and Park (2018) and the Clinton and Khan (2019) meta-analysis. It shows the scope of each and what it found for learning and for withdrawal or DFW rates. Quality and programme leads can use it to set realistic expectations before evaluating an open textbook adoption. Koji can collect the student side, such as access to the text and reasons for nearly leaving, through short course evaluation interviews.

What's in this reference table

StudyScopeLearningOther finding
Hilton (2016)16 studies, 9 on learningSame outcomes in generalStudents and faculty generally positive
Hilton (2020)16 efficacy studies, 114,419 studentsSame or better20 perception studies as well
Colvard et al. (2018)21,822 students at one universityHigher course gradesLower DFW rates, larger for Pell and part-time students
Clinton and Khan (2019)Meta-analysis, US and CanadaNo difference (g = 0.01)Lower withdrawal (odds ratio 0.71)

Use this image

Free to use in your docs, decks and posts under CC BY 4.0, as long as you credit Koji with a link to this page. To embed it, paste this into your page:

html
<a href="https://www.koji.so/visuals/open-textbook-research-syntheses-compared"><img src="https://www.koji.so/visuals/open-textbook-research-syntheses-compared/open-textbook-research-syntheses-compared.png" alt="Table comparing four studies of open textbooks: learning stays about the same, while withdrawal and DFW rates fall after adoption." width="1200" height="744" /></a>
<p>Source: <a href="https://www.koji.so/visuals/open-textbook-research-syntheses-compared">Open textbooks and student outcomes: four studies</a>, Koji</p>