All frameworks and cheat sheets

Reference table

Course evaluation vs KOAB vs the DZHW graduate panel

Three ways German universities collect evidence about a programme

Table comparing course evaluation, the KOAB graduate survey and the DZHW graduate panel by who runs them, timing, who is asked, best use and main limit.
Three instruments, three different questions about the same programme Source: INCHER-Kassel, ISTAT and DZHW project documentation

A comparison of three sources of programme evidence used in Germany: module-level course evaluation, the KOAB graduate survey run by universities about 18 months after graduation, and the national DZHW Graduate Panel. Programme directors and accreditation leads can use it to decide which question each instrument answers. Koji adds short graduate interviews that explain the survey results.

What's in this reference table

Course evaluationKOAB graduate surveyDZHW graduate panel
Who runs itEach universityUniversities, with a shared core, coordinated by ISTATDZHW, nationally
WhenDuring or at the end of a moduleAbout 1.5 years after graduation, then 3 years laterAbout 1, 5 and 10 years after graduation
Who is askedStudents in the moduleEach participating university's graduatesA sample of every fourth graduate cohort
Best forFixing a module while it runsProgramme review: outcomes and studies in hindsightNational trends in careers and job match
Main limitCannot see what happens after graduationUneven response rates, hindsight shaped by outcomesToo few graduates from any one programme

Use this image

Free to use in your docs, decks and posts under CC BY 4.0, as long as you credit Koji with a link to this page. To embed it, paste this into your page:

html
<a href="https://www.koji.so/visuals/course-evaluation-vs-koab-vs-dzhw-graduate-panel"><img src="https://www.koji.so/visuals/course-evaluation-vs-koab-vs-dzhw-graduate-panel/course-evaluation-vs-koab-vs-dzhw-graduate-panel.png" alt="Table comparing course evaluation, the KOAB graduate survey and the DZHW graduate panel by who runs them, timing, who is asked, best use and main limit." width="1200" height="873" /></a>
<p>Source: <a href="https://www.koji.so/visuals/course-evaluation-vs-koab-vs-dzhw-graduate-panel">Course evaluation vs KOAB vs the DZHW graduate panel</a>, Koji</p>