Reference table
Scotland's TQEF: student feedback evidence map

A one-page map for quality teams at Scottish colleges and universities working under the Tertiary Quality Enhancement Framework. Each row takes one TQEF element, such as the SEAP self-evaluation, the action plan, TQER or annual quality engagement, and sets out what reviewers look for and which student feedback output can supply it. It follows SFC guidance and QAA Scotland and sparqs material, and notes that externality still comes from examiners and peer review.
What's in this reference table
| TQEF element | What reviewers look for | Koji output |
|---|---|---|
| SEAP self-evaluation | Key themes from student feedback, briefly, with evidence | Themed reports with verbatim quotes, as slides or PDF |
| SEAP action plan | Actions linked to what students said, with follow-up | A repeat study with the same brief after the change |
| Student partnership | Students shaping the evidence and seeing the outcome | Read-only access for student officers; slides to share back |
| TQER and impact analysis | Impact of enhancement work over time | Dated reports from before and after each change |
| Annual quality engagement | A current picture staff and students discuss together | A short report on the year's priority themes |
| Institution-led review | Programme-level student views | One study per programme, fixed ratings plus follow-ups |
| Supporting student success | Views from groups standard surveys miss | Text or voice in 30+ languages; dictation; resume |
| Data and evidence | Sound method and honest limits | Interviews scored 1 to 5; only 3+ reported |
| Externality | Independent judgement from outside | Not replaced by Koji: examiners, peer reviewers, QAA |
Use this image
Free to use in your docs, decks and posts under CC BY 4.0, as long as you credit Koji with a link to this page. To embed it, paste this into your page:
<a href="https://www.koji.so/visuals/tqef-scotland-student-feedback-evidence-map"><img src="https://www.koji.so/visuals/tqef-scotland-student-feedback-evidence-map/tqef-scotland-student-feedback-evidence-map.png" alt="Table mapping Scotland's TQEF elements, including the SEAP, TQER and annual quality engagement, to the evidence reviewers expect and matching Koji outputs" width="1200" height="1114" /></a>
<p>Source: <a href="https://www.koji.so/visuals/tqef-scotland-student-feedback-evidence-map">Scotland's TQEF: student feedback evidence map</a>, Koji</p>Related

ANECA AUDIT criteria mapped to student feedback evidence

Student feedback evidence checklist for a cross-border QA review

Customer baseline methods compared for PE

Paging vs scrolling surveys: what the studies found

Verbatim vs clean verbatim vs intelligent verbatim

Four ways to run confirmatory customer calls